Retargeting Strategies That Convert: A Guide for Small Businesses

At Inspired Connection Agency, we’ve worked with businesses across dozens of industries—from home service contractors and local gyms to auto shops and retail boutiques. And one of the biggest missed opportunities we see across the board? Retargeting.

You've spent time and money getting someone to your website. Maybe they clicked your Google ad, found you through a social post, or typed in your name after seeing your sign on a job site. But then... they leave. No form submitted. No call. No sale. And that’s where retargeting becomes your secret weapon.

In this blog, we’re going to break down retargeting strategies that actually convert, how they work, and how businesses like yours can use them to increase ROI, re-engage leads, and generate more paying customers without blowing the budget.

What Is Retargeting?

Let’s start with the basics.

Retargeting is a type of digital marketing that targets people who have already interacted with your brand—whether they visited your website, clicked an ad, engaged on social media, or even added an item to their cart but didn’t complete a purchase.

Instead of starting from scratch with cold traffic, you’re focusing on warm leads—people who’ve already shown interest in what you do. And that’s why retargeting is one of the most cost-effective forms of digital advertising.

Why? Because people are far more likely to take action the second, third, or fourth time they interact with your business.

The Problem Most Businesses Face

Most companies we talk to are spending money on front-end ads (like Google search or Facebook cold audience campaigns), but they don’t have a system to follow up with the people who don’t convert right away.

Think about this:

• 96% of visitors will leave your website without converting.

• Most of them won’t remember your name.

• And unless you give them a reason to come back, they probably won’t.

That’s why retargeting is not optional—it’s essential. And it’s not just for e-commerce. If you’re a plumber, roofer, chiropractor, gym owner, or any other service provider—you can retarget leads and win more business.

Retargeting Strategy #1: Website Visitor Retargeting

This is the foundation of every solid retargeting plan.

When someone visits your website, you can place a tracking pixel (a small piece of code) from platforms like Facebook or Google. This lets you follow up with tailored ads across other platforms and devices.

Let’s say a homeowner lands on your roof repair page but doesn’t call. With retargeting in place, you can show them a Facebook ad the next day that says, “Storm damage? Don’t wait. Book a free roof inspection today!”

These ads feel personal and relevant—and that’s what drives conversions.

Pro Tips:

• Segment your retargeting audiences by page visited (e.g., someone who viewed your ‘Gutter Services’ page sees gutter-related ads).

• Cap frequency to avoid annoying your leads.

• Refresh creative every few weeks to avoid ad fatigue.

Retargeting Strategy #2: Abandoned Form or Checkout Follow-Up

For e-commerce brands or service businesses with booking forms, this one’s gold.

Let’s say a customer starts filling out a “Request a Quote” form but never hits submit. That’s a high-intent lead—and you can retarget them with ads or email sequences encouraging them to finish.

You might say:

• “Still thinking about it? Schedule your free consultation today!”

• “Spots are filling up fast—don’t miss out!”

These micro-reminders push hesitant users to follow through.

Pro Tips:

• Connect your forms to retargeting events (like ‘form initiated’ vs. ‘form submitted’).

• Use urgency or limited-time offers to encourage action.

• Include testimonials or trust-building messages in your ads.

Retargeting Strategy #3: Video Engagement Retargeting

Video content is a powerful way to build trust. And with platforms like Meta Ads (Facebook/Instagram), you can retarget people who watched a certain percentage of your videos.

For example:

• Run a short video introducing your services.

• Retarget people who watched 50%+ with a lead generation ad or service offer.

Why does this work?

Because people who watch your videos are already engaged. You’re simply moving them down the funnel.

Pro Tips:

• Use video to educate or entertain—not just sell.

• Short and punchy is better (15–45 seconds).

• Always include your brand, value prop, and a clear call-to-action.

Retargeting Strategy #4: Email List Retargeting

Already have a customer list or email subscribers? Great—upload that list to ad platforms and run specific campaigns just for them.

Here’s how we use this strategy:

• Send seasonal promos to past customers.

• Offer upsells or complementary services.

• Win back old leads who haven’t converted.

This strategy works especially well for:

• Contractors with a past client base.

• Chiropractors who want to reactivate old patients.

• Gym owners offering a new promotion to lapsed members.

Pro Tips:

• Keep lists clean and updated.

• Use messaging that feels personalized (e.g., “Hey John, ready to finish your kitchen remodel?”).

• Combine email and ad retargeting for maximum impact.

Retargeting Strategy #5: Dynamic Product or Service Ads

For businesses with multiple offerings—like auto repair shops, trailer dealers, or retailers—dynamic ads show users exactly what they viewed.

If someone browsed your "Flatbed Trailers" section, they’ll see an ad featuring flatbed trailers, not general branding.

This level of customization drives higher CTRs and more conversions.

Even if you’re a service provider, this can work by dynamically showing services or service packages based on past behavior.

Pro Tips:

• Sync your website catalog to platforms like Meta or Google.

• Use product or service categories as filters.

• Add “trust triggers” like reviews, pricing, or financing options in the ad.

Retargeting Strategy #6: Geotargeted Retargeting

If your business is local, location matters. You don’t want to waste ad dollars showing retargeting ads to someone 500 miles away.

Instead:

• Use geo-fencing to retarget visitors in your actual service area.

• Or combine location + behavior (e.g., people who visited your site and live within 25 miles of your business).

This is especially useful for:

• Local service businesses (e.g., plumbing, roofing, cleaning).

• Event-based promotions (e.g., grand openings, seasonal deals).

• Multi-location businesses targeting specific markets.

Pro Tips:

• Combine geotargeting with interest or behavior layers.

• A/B test offers based on location.

• Consider weather-related targeting (e.g., roofing ads after a hailstorm).

Retargeting Strategy #7: Sequential Messaging

Don’t just show the same ad over and over. Create a sequential journey for your audience.

Example 4-day funnel for a home service provider:

• Day 1: Ad introducing your company.

• Day 2: Ad with a testimonial or before/after project.

• Day 3: Special offer or free quote call-to-action.

• Day 4: Scarcity message (“Only 3 spots left this week!”)

This storytelling approach builds trust, credibility, and urgency—without being pushy.

Pro Tips:

• Use storytelling formats like carousels or video series.

• Build sequences in Meta Ads Manager or Google Ads.

• Measure where users are dropping off and tweak accordingly.

Retargeting Strategy #8: Google Display and YouTube Retargeting

Most people don’t know that you can retarget people across Google’s massive display network—or even show video ads on YouTube.

This gives you access to:

• Banner ads on news, lifestyle, and hobby sites.

• YouTube pre-roll or in-stream video ads.

These placements are cost-effective and great for brand recall.

Let’s say someone visits your site and doesn’t convert. A day later, they’re watching a how-to video on YouTube, and they see your ad offering a free consultation. That’s strategic positioning.

Pro Tips:

• Design clean, mobile-friendly display ads.

• Keep video ads short (6–15 seconds for YouTube bumper ads).

• Optimize bids for conversions, not just impressions.

The Bottom Line: Why Retargeting Works

Retargeting isn’t about nagging people—it’s about meeting them where they are.

Most people don’t buy on the first visit. They’re busy. Distracted. Comparing options. Life happens.

Retargeting gives them a second (or third) chance to remember why they were interested in the first place. And when done right, it dramatically boosts your conversions without increasing your overall ad spend.

Final Thought: Let’s Make Retargeting Work for You

At Inspired Connection Agency, we don’t just run ads—we build systems that bring people back, build trust, and turn warm leads into loyal customers.

Whether you’re a home service business, fitness center, healthcare provider, or e-commerce brand, retargeting can be the missing piece in your marketing strategy.

If you’re ready to unlock the power of retargeting and want help setting up campaigns that actually convert, contact us today for a free SEO and website checkup. We’ll review your current digital presence and show you exactly how to plug in retargeting for better results.

Let’s turn those clicks into customers—together.

ou have not enough Humanizer words left. Upgrade your Surfer plan.